Easy 5-Ingredient Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream Recipe

pumpkin, ice cream, psl


Easy 5-Ingredient Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream Recipe

Written by: Lindsay Sibson

Last fall, it was all about the “PSL.”

You couldn’t enter a coffee shop without advertisements screaming in your face to enjoy the ever-so-popular pumpkin spice latte.

However, this fall there is a new taste in town… the PPIC!

That’s right, pumpkin pie ice cream is the flavor that is begging to dominate your taste buds this autumn.

Unlike the PSL, which is full of dairy and refined sugar, this PPIC is dairy free, vegan and made with a healthier sugar alternative.

Check it out below!

Benefits Of Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream

Coconut Milk
  • A great alternative for people who have dairy sensitivities or allergies
  • Has anti-inflammatory and anti-fungal properties
  • Full of antioxidants
  • Easy to digest
  • Stimulates your metabolism
  • Excellent source of fiber: helps your stay fuller longer
  • Packed with vitamin C, which helps boost your immune system
  • Full of the antioxidant beta-carotene
    • Helps neutralize free radicals
    • When your body has too many free radicals, it causes cell damage, which can accelerate the progression of cancer and other diseases
  • Helps protect your skin from the sun’s wrinkle-causing UV rays (thanks to the beta-carotene!)
Maple Syrup
  • Supplies some trace mineral and antioxidants
  • A more natural, unrefined product than cane and other sugars
  • Provides inflammation-reducing polyphenol antioxidants

Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream


  • 2 cans of full-fat coconut milk (15 ounces each)
  • 1 cup pumpkin (home-roasted or canned)
  • ½ cup maple syrup
  • 2 tsp pumpkin pie spice
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract 


OPTION 1: Ice Cream Machine

1. Blend all of the ingredients in a blender until smooth.

2. Pour mixture into the ice cream machine and follow the manufacturer’s directions.

      • Approximately 30 minutes.

3. Cover the ice cream and put into the freezer to allow to further harden for 1-2 hours.

OPTION 2: WITHOUT Ice Cream Maker

1. Pour the blended ice cream mixture into an uncovered container and put in the freezer.

2. EVERY 30 minutes, vigorously stir the mixture and place it back in the freezer.

      • Continue stirring every 30 minutes for 3 hours.

3. Store ice cream in a covered container until ready to serve.

TIP: For the best flavor and texture, this ice cream is best eaten FRESH (shortly after it is made).


Do you have a favorite PUMPKIN recipe? Please SHARE with us in the comments below!



Lindsay Sibson

Lindsay Sibson

Lindsay Sibson turned her lifelong dream of traveling the world into a reality when she first stepped on a plan in April of 2014. With the simple intention of learning more about this beautiful world, she stepped away from corporate America to explore an alternative lifestyle of long term international travel, volunteering, blogging and pursuing a blissfully happy and fulfilling way of life.

Lindsay documents her journey in hopes of empowering others to find their passion, reignite their spark and freshen their outlook on life. Connect with her on her website and follow her travels on Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/_traveloholic_).

Through her blog, Lindsay documents her journey in hopes of empowering others to find their passion, reignite their spark and freshen their outlook on life.
Lindsay Sibson

Latest posts by Lindsay Sibson (see all)


What Our Clients Say*

During my FitLife transformation, I lost 70 pounds! That's why I signed up for the protocol, but the most exciting result is that I found ME in the process. I had been hiding under a pile of pounds, self-doubt, and grief! FitLife changed my life and I knew I had to share it with others.

-Lynne, Longwood FL

I started with Fitlife back in 2011-2012…I wrote into Fitlife asking for an extreme amount of help. I was 300 pounds, with high cholesterol, and Drew helped me transform my life. I lost over 130 pounds and I no longer have high cholesterol. Not only did I lose weight, so did my husband, who lost over 70 pounds!

-Jaclyn, Martinsburg NE
View More Testimonials
*Results may vary by individual

Join The Movement

Mindset MasteryNutritional GuidanceFitness TipsCommunity Support
Join Now